2012 Lexus GX 460 vs. 2012 Land Rover LR4

The 2012 Land Rover LR4 and the 2012 Lexus GX 460 are comparable in almost every way. While the LR4 has certain advantages that derive from its larger engine and its specialized off-road systems, the Lexus enjoys greater fuel efficiency, a better warranty, and a reputation for quality. While the Land Rover LR4 V8 has a starting MSRP of $49,750.00, to compare prices fairly we should note that the LR4 HSE and the GX 460 feature nearly identical MSRPs, as do the LR4 HSE LUX and the GX 460 Premium.

Setting aside intangibles such as the aesthetics, the Land Rover’s greatest advantage over the Lexus GX 460 comes from its purpose-built off-road systems and its more powerful V8 engine. The LR4’s engines offers 74 more horsepower than the 4.6L V8 found in the Lexus, which in turn gives the LR4 the advantage when it comes to payload an towing capacity. However, this larger engine is thirstier, and lags the Lexus by 3 combined MPG; not an insignificant amount over the lifetime of the vehicle. When comparing powertrains, it should also be noted that both vehicles in all trims are full-time 4WD.

Unless you plan on going off-road or have an affinity for the Land Rover’s heritage, a final buying decision might just come down to aesthetics. Each vehicle features a certain amount of distinctive visual appeal. Where the LR4 is traditional Land Rover boxy, the Lexus has much more fluid and sculpted look.

Quick Look

  Introductory MSRP Tie (Trim-vs-Trim)
  Powertrain LR4
  Off-Road Capability LR4
  Fuel Economy GX 460
  Warranty GX 460
  Interior Room LR4
  Towing LR4
  Emissions Tie
  Reliability GX 460
  Airbags GX 460
     

LR4 vs. GX 460 Reliability

Another significant advantage that the GX 460 enjoys is Lexus’ reputation for reliability. In J.D. Power and Associates’ 2011 Initial Quality Study, Lexus as a brand enjoyed a five-circle (“among the best” in J.D.Power-speak) rating for Overall Quality. Land Rover as a brand scored just two circles (“the rest”). Specifically, J.D. Power and Associates named the GX 460 the “Highest Ranked Midsize Premium Crossover/SUV in Initial Quality” for 2011. 

  2012 Land Rover LR4 2012 Lexus GX 460
  2012 Land Rover Discovery 4 (LR4) 2012 Lexus GX 460
 
MSRP (w/ Destination Fee) $49,750.00 (V8)
MSRP (w/ Destination Fee) $53,975.00 (HSE) $54,120.00 (460)
MSRP (w/ Destination Fee) $58,995.00 (HSE LUX) $58,915.00 (460 Premium)
     
Powertrain
Engine(s) 5.0L V8 4.6L V8
Horsepower 375 HP @ 6,500 RPM 301 HP @ 5,500 RPM
Torque 375 ft.-lbs. @ 3,500 RPM 329 ft.-lbs. @ 3,500 RPM
Transmission 6-Speed Automatic 6-Speed Automatic
     
Performance
0-60 MPH 7.5 Seconds 7.8 Seconds
Top Track Speed 121 MPH 110 MPH
     
Fuel Economy    
MPG (EPA City) 12 15
MPG (EPA Highway) 17 20
Combined MPG 14 17
Fuel Capacity (Gallons) 22.8 23
     

Interior Dimensions (Inches)

Headroom Front 40.4 38
Headroom Second 42.4 40.4
Headroom Third 40.1 35.2
Legroom Front 42.4 41.7
Legroom Second 37.6 34.1
Legroom Third 36.3 29.3
Shoulder Room Front 59.2 55.4
Shoulder Room Second 59 57.3
Shoulder Room Third 42.8 54.5
     
Passengers 5 (7) 7
     
Exterior Clearances
Approach Angle 37.2° (Off-Road Mode) 28°
Breakover 29.9° (Off-Road Mode) 21°
Departure Angle 29.6° (Off-Road Mode) 25°
Ground Clerance (Inches) 7.3 – 9.4 8.1
Turning Circle 37.6 Feet 38.1 Feet
     
Exterior Dimensions (Inches)
Wheelbase 113.6 109.8
Length 190.1 189.2
Width 85.7 74.2

Height

74.1 73.8
Weight (Curb) 5,833 Pounds (V8) 5,305 Pounds (460)
     
Warranties (Months/Miles)
Basic Warranty 48/50,000 48/50,000
Powertrain 48/50,000 72/70,000
Corrosion 72/Unlimited 72/Unlimited
     
Environmental Ratings
CARB Rating ULEV II ULEV II
EPA Air Pollution Score 6/10 6/10
EPA Greenhouse Gas Score 2/10 2/10
     
Towing & Payload
Towing 7,716 Pounds 6,500 Pounds
Payload 1,325 Pounds 1,295 Pounds (460)
Cargo Capacity (Cubic Feet) 90.3 Maximum 91.9 Maximum
     
Safety    
Airbags  6 (8) 10
     


Enter Your Email:

December 25, 2011

RoverGuide

Buying & Ownership, Comparisons, Land Rover Models, LR4

Comparison, Lexus, LR4

Related Posts

Land Rover Discovery XXV Special Edition
02/17/2014

25 Years: Land Rover Discovery XXV Special Edition

In 2012, Land Rover celebrated the production of the 1,000,000th Discovery with an 8,000-mile Journey of Discovery. The company is now celebrating another major milestone: 25 years of Discovery production. Introducing the Discovery XXV Special Edition.

Read Story
2012 Evoque and Discovery 4 Awards
07/02/2012

Two More Awards for the Evoque, One for Discovery

The 2012 Range Rover Evoque has been honored with the 2012 MacRobert Award and also took home a 2012 Auto Express Award. Not to be outdone, the Land Rover Discovery 4 (LR4) also was a top contender in this year's Auto Express Award series.

Read Story